You may wonder now “What is the purpose of dissertation critique? Can’t I just read someone’s project and draw own conclusions about it?”
Probably, the second option is easier. But you know, it will be less effective and useful for your own project. The point is that dissertation critique allows you to look at the most significant aspects of a dissertation and decide on the best ways to complete your own project.
So, let us not waste your time and tell about the main elements that your dissertation critique should include.
Dissertation critique: element 1
You have to start with discussing the overall purpose of a dissertation. Particularly, you need to evaluate the clarity of the project and its potential impact. Thus, when writing this section of your dissertation critique, tell whether you find a statement clear and results of the project significant.
Dissertation critique: element 2
The second part of your dissertation critique will be devoted to the dissertation literature review section. Your major mission is to decide whether the topic was studied comprehensively. Answer the following questions:
- How did the author choose works of literature?
- Do you think some important sources relevant to the topic are missed?
- How can you evaluate the quality of sources?
- How did the author summarize and analyze sources?
Dissertation critique: element 3
The last part of your dissertation critique touches upon research design. You have to estimate the reliability and effectiveness of research methods selected by the author. Include the following details in this section of your dissertation critique:
- the type of research selected by the author: qualitative or quantitative;
- methods and instruments used to obtain results;
- author’s ability to generalize obtained results.
Read our next article if you want to know more about writing a good dissertation.